Trusted Farmers
A feel-good phrase that replaces scrutiny with happy vibes.
The Claim
They Say…
From our trusted farmers
They Say…
From select farms we know and trust
We Say…
Does Tesco trust the Cranswick farmers who smashed piglets into concrete floors?3
Does M&S trust the farmers who allow extreme crowding, death, and disease on their free-range egg farms?4
“Trusted” doesn’t mean transparent. It doesn't mean high welfare. We don't know what it does mean.
The Reality
There is no legal or regulatory definition of what a “trusted farmer” should be. The term merely refers to the farmers that supermarkets have contracts with, and say they trust. But how do they know they can trust them and what is it exactly that they are trusting them to do? Or not to do.
There have been dozens of investigations into UK farms in just the last five years that have revealed widespread suffering, appalling conditions, mutilations, pregnant animals confined in cages, illegal abuse, and widespread breaches of environmental regulations. 5 6 7 Many of these are connected to supermarkets who say they trust their farmers.
For example, at one M&S farm, investigators found hens who had collapsed, others suffering from injuries such as suspected prolapsed cloacas, as well as feather loss and overgrown nails which made it difficult for the birds even to walk. 9
And did Tesco trust the Bakkafrost salmon farm found dumping diseased fish into a sea loch and allowing others to suffocate to death?10
What They Don't Show You
Still discovered under this welfare term:
Who Uses This
The Bottom Line
We have no idea what the supermarkets are trusting factory farmers to do. Apart from causing systemic suffering and widespread pollution.
Investigation and Reports
Tesco trusted farmer found thumping piglets
Supermarkets halt supplies from Lincolnshire pig farm over animal abuse footage
Factory farm supplying Tesco, Sainsbury's and Asda where helpless piglets are beaten to death
References
- 1. https://www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/294007923
- 2. https://www.marksandspencer.com/food/northern-irish-free-range-omega-3-enriched-large-eggs/p/fdp60065709#intid=pid_pg1pip96g6r2c3
- 3. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cy0457dw26ro
- 4. https://www.animaljusticeproject.com/post/horrific-conditions-at-high-welfare-farms-supplying-marks-and-spencer-and-happy-egg
- 5. https://animalequality.org.uk/news/2024/07/09/investigation-inside-red-tractor-certified-pig-farm-supplying-tesco-reveals-dead-piglets-and-caged-mother-pigs/
- 6. https://investigations.peta.org/marks-spencer-cruelty-chicken-farms/
- 7. https://www.sustainweb.org/news/apr24-10-companies-produce-as-much-excrement-as-10-largest-uk-cities/
- 8. https://www.animaljusticeproject.com/post/horrific-conditions-at-high-welfare-farms-supplying-marks-and-spencer-and-happy-egg
- 9. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c9wx0l99457o